Joey’s Pizza of Hamilton: A Slice of New Jersey's Best Pizza Experience

This is our go to delivery pizza place. The pizza is great but it's also a smooth process for delivering online or in person/on the phone. The deliverymen are always respectful and nice, and always earlier than they say. I'm so glad I tried this place out. The pizza is delicious and a classic Jersey pie with great crusts. The wings are also great for a party. My go to pizza place, I wish they had a rewards program

This is by far the BEST pizza in town and maybe our favorite ever!! Joeys has become our go to for pizza and sandwiches since we first tried it a few months ago. The delivery is always quick and fresh!!

Pizza and pizza steak were both delicious, but a little too greasy. The Sprite tasted terrible, but other than that the other two drinks were great and the fries were amazing as well.

Was the pizza good? Yes, was it made the way I asked? No. But I would try it again and make sure the hostess actually reads my order back to me.

Such a great place to have a party. Margarita pizza is to die for! So kind and accommodating. Also a clean and spacious place for a larger group

Loved this place. Had the small stromboli with sausage. It was awesome! The sausage is very tasty and the cheese is excellent. Oh and love the sauce. The picture is what I came home with. Oh, and my server Marilyn was excellent. Great place and I will be back.

First time I went to Joey's Pizza. The pizza is by far the best I ate ever. It seems they do something different when they prepare their pizzas. We had the medium pizza, half with pepperoni and half with tomato, mozzarella and basil. Very very good. As a starter we had some medium spicey chickenwings, also very tasteful. We spoke a little while with the owner. 30 Years of experience. And very special, I have never seen one: a rotating pizza oven with 4 stoors. He didn't want to talk about his way of preparation and recipes...a secret he wont tell!! Very kind service. All home made products!! Everybody in the neighbourhood should at least try a Joey's Pizza.

Joey’s Pizza is seriously one of the more delightful finds in the neighborhood. From the moment you step inside, it feels inviting — clean floors, tidy tables, and a bright counter area that makes you confident they take pride in their space. The restrooms and common areas are kept in great shape too, which always boosts my appetite rather than dampening it. Now, let’s talk about their calzone — wow. It’s absolutely amazing. It arrives piping hot, with a golden-brown crust that’s crisp on the edges yet soft inside. The filling is generous and perfectly balanced: gooey cheese, savory meats (if you choose), fresh herbs, and a sauce that gives just the right tang. It isn’t overstuffed to the point of collapse, but it never leaves you wanting more. The staff here deserve applause. They’re consistently friendly and seem to love what they do. Every time I’ve been, they greet you with a smile, offer suggestions when you ask, and make the whole ordering process feel personal rather than robotic. What really seals the deal is how fast they cook. I’ve never waited long, even during busier times. You place your order, and almost before you know it your food is ready. The efficiency never seems to compromise quality — everything is delivered hot, fresh, and full of flavor. If you’re in the mood for Italian comfort food done right — a clean, welcoming place, friendly faces, speedy service, and a calzone that might just become your new favorite — Joey’s Pizza absolutely delivers.